CATEGORIES

Gift Cards & Certificates
Aged Cheese
Blue Cheese
Bricks and Havarti
Candy
Cheddars
Cheese Curds
String Cheese
Cheese Spreads
Colby, Jacks, & Goudas
Gift Baskets and Boxes
Gourmet
HOT, HOT, HOT!
Italian and Brie Cheeses
Low Fat and Low Salt Cheeses
Sausage & Salami
Snack Sticks & Beef Jerky
Merchandise
Cheddar Cheese Wax
NEW Products!
Top Ten Customer Favorites
Pasteurized Processed Cheeses
Smoked Cheeses
Swiss
Unique & Specialty Cheeses

Cheddars

Our award-winning cheddars aged right here on site! From mild cheddar all the way up to 16-year-old cheddar! We have the cheddars aimed to please!

We're really sorry...

We don't currently have that one in stock

Please add your email and we'll notify you when it's back

Home

» Cheddars

Sort by

5 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 1lb

In Stock 10101

White sharp cheddar aged for about 5 years. Semi-crumbly texture. Has natural white color. No food coloring added. 1 lb.

Price$16.98

5 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 1lb

In Stock 10101

White sharp cheddar aged for about 5 years. Semi-crumbly texture. Has natural white color. No food coloring added. 1 lb.

Price$16.98

5 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 5.5lb

In Stock 10177

White sharp cheddar aged for about 5 years. Semi-crumbly texture. Has natural white color. No food coloring added. 5.5 lbs.

Price$90.95

5 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 5.5lb

In Stock 10177

White sharp cheddar aged for about 5 years. Semi-crumbly texture. Has natural white color. No food coloring added. 5.5 lbs.

Price$90.95

7 Year Old Extra Sharp Cheddar 1lb

In Stock 4093

Extra sharp cheddar aged by us for 7 years. Very sharp flavor. Texture is very dry and crumbly. This cheese is one of our specialties! 1 lb. This is one of our Top Ten Customer Favorites!!

Price$21.98

7 Year Old Extra Sharp Cheddar 1lb

In Stock 4093

Extra sharp cheddar aged by us for 7 years. Very sharp flavor. Texture is very dry and crumbly. This cheese is one of our specialties! 1 lb. This is one of our Top Ten Customer Favorites!!

Price$21.98

7 Year Old Extra Sharp Cheddar 5.5lb

In Stock 10171

Extra sharp cheddar aged by us for 7 years. Very sharp flavor. Texture is very dry and crumbly. This cheese is one of our specialties! 5.5 lbs.

Price$117.95

7 Year Old Extra Sharp Cheddar 5.5lb

In Stock 10171

Extra sharp cheddar aged by us for 7 years. Very sharp flavor. Texture is very dry and crumbly. This cheese is one of our specialties! 5.5 lbs.

Price$117.95

Applewood Smoked Variety Pack 1lb

In Stock 1135

Can't decide which one to have? You do not have to with this Variety pack that contains four of some of the most popular Wisconsin cheese: Colby, Colby Jack, Mild Cheddar and Monterey Jack. 1 lb. This is one of our Top Ten Customer Favorites in our Smoked Cheese Category!

Price$10.98

Applewood Smoked Variety Pack 1lb

In Stock 1135

Price$10.98

Applewood Smoked Variety Pack 5lb

In Stock 1173

Can't decide which one to have? You do not have to with this Variety pack that contains four of some of the most popular Wisconsin cheese: Colby, Colby Jack, Mild Cheddar and Monterey Jack. 5 lbs.

Price$52.95

Applewood Smoked Variety Pack 5lb

In Stock 1173

Can't decide which one to have? You do not have to with this Variety pack that contains four of some of the most popular Wisconsin cheese: Colby, Colby Jack, Mild Cheddar and Monterey Jack. 5 lbs.

Price$52.95

Blueberry Cheddar 1lb

In Stock 10146

Great as a dessert cheese, our Blueberry Cheddar features white sharp cheddar with blueberries added. 1 lb.

Price$12.98

Blueberry Cheddar 1lb

In Stock 10146

Great as a dessert cheese, our Blueberry Cheddar features white sharp cheddar with blueberries added. 1 lb.

Price$12.98

Blueberry Cheddar 5.5lb

In Stock 10175

Great as a dessert cheese, our Blueberry Cheddar features white sharp cheddar with blueberries added. 5.5 lbs.

Price$68.95

Blueberry Cheddar 5.5lb

In Stock 10175

Great as a dessert cheese, our Blueberry Cheddar features white sharp cheddar with blueberries added. 5.5 lbs.

Price$68.95

Cranberry Cheddar 1lb

In Stock 10091

Great as a dessert cheese, our Cranberry Cheddar Cheese features white sharp cheddar with cranberries added. 1 lb. This is one of our Top Ten Customer Favorites!!

Price$12.98

Cranberry Cheddar 1lb

In Stock 10091

Great as a dessert cheese, our Cranberry Cheddar Cheese features white sharp cheddar with cranberries added. 1 lb. This is one of our Top Ten Customer Favorites!!

Price$12.98

Cranberry Cheddar 5.5lb

In Stock 10176

Great as a dessert cheese, our Cranberry Cheddar Cheese features white sharp cheddar with cranberries added. 5.5 lbs.

Price$68.95

Cranberry Cheddar 5.5lb

In Stock 10176

Great as a dessert cheese, our Cranberry Cheddar Cheese features white sharp cheddar with cranberries added. 5.5 lbs.

Price$68.95

Double Jalapeno Cheddar 1lb

In Stock 10158

1 lb. Double Jalapeno Cheddar is a mild white cheddar with twice the jalapenos added.

Price$10.98

Double Jalapeno Cheddar 1lb

In Stock 10158

1 lb. Double Jalapeno Cheddar is a mild white cheddar with twice the jalapenos added.

Price$10.98

Double Jalapeno Cheddar 5lb

In Stock 10175

5 lbs. Double Jalapeno Cheddar is a mild white cheddar with twice the jalapenos added.

Price$52.95

Double Jalapeno Cheddar 5lb

In Stock 10175

5 lbs. Double Jalapeno Cheddar is a mild white cheddar with twice the jalapenos added.

Price$52.95

Fear the Reaper Cheddar 1lb

In Stock 10291

One of our hottest cheeses, our Fear the Reaper Cheddar is a mild cheddar with Carolina Reaper peppers added. Not for the faint of heart! 1 lb. This is one of our Top Ten Customer Favorites!!

Price$14.98

Fear the Reaper Cheddar 1lb

In Stock 10291

One of our hottest cheeses, our Fear the Reaper Cheddar is a mild cheddar with Carolina Reaper peppers added. Not for the faint of heart! 1 lb. This is one of our Top Ten Customer Favorites!!

Price$14.98

Ghost Habanero Cheddar 5lb

In Stock 10173

One of our hottest cheeses, our Ghost Habanero Cheddar is a mild cheddar with ghost chili & habanero peppers added. Not for the faint of heart! 5.5 lbs.

Price$62.95

Ghost Habanero Cheddar 5lb

In Stock 10173

One of our hottest cheeses, our Ghost Habanero Cheddar is a mild cheddar with ghost chili & habanero peppers added. Not for the faint of heart! 5.5 lbs.

Price$62.95

Hickory Smoked Bacon Cheddar 1lb

In Stock 217

A great mix of Cheddar and Bacon. We then Hickory Smoke the product for even more flavor. 1 lb.

Price$11.98

Hickory Smoked Bacon Cheddar 1lb

In Stock 217

A great mix of Cheddar and Bacon. We then Hickory Smoke the product for even more flavor. 1 lb.

Price$11.98

Hickory Smoked Bacon Cheddar 5lb

In Stock 224

A great mix of Cheddar and Bacon. We then Hickory Smoke the product for even more flavor. 5 lbs.

Price$57.95

Hickory Smoked Bacon Cheddar 5lb

In Stock 224

A great mix of Cheddar and Bacon. We then Hickory Smoke the product for even more flavor. 5 lbs.

Price$57.95

Hickory Smoked Blueberry Cheddar (1lb)

In Stock 1163

White cheddar with blueberries throughout that has been hickory smoked on site! Hickory Smoked Blueberry Cheddar is one of our Smoked Top Ten Customer Favorites! Weight: 1lb

Price$14.98

Hickory Smoked Blueberry Cheddar (1lb)

In Stock 1163

White cheddar with blueberries throughout that has been hickory smoked on site! Hickory Smoked Blueberry Cheddar is one of our Smoked Top Ten Customer Favorites! Weight: 1lb

Price$14.98

Hickory Smoked Blueberry Cheddar (5lb)

In Stock 10173

White cheddar with blueberries throughout that has been hickory smoked on site! Hickory Smoked Blueberry Cheddar is one of our Smoked Top Ten Customer Favorites! Weight: 5lb (whole block)

Price$71.95

Hickory Smoked Blueberry Cheddar (5lb)

In Stock 10173

White cheddar with blueberries throughout that has been hickory smoked on site! Hickory Smoked Blueberry Cheddar is one of our Smoked Top Ten Customer Favorites! Weight: 5lb (whole block)

Price$71.95

« Previous1234Next »