4879 County Road V
DeForest, WI 53532
Phone: 608-846-4791
Fax: 608-846-4793

0 Product(s) in cart |
Total $0.00 |
 Shopping cart
Not logged in

CATEGORIES


Cheddars

Our award-winning cheddar aged right here on site! From mild cheddar all the way up to 21-year-old cheddar! We have the cheddar aimed to please!

Home
» Cheddars
Sort by
12 Year Sharp Cheddar 1lb
12 Year Sharp Cheddar 1lb
In Stock 47
Sharp cheddar aged by us over 12 years. 1 lb.
Price$51.99
17 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 1lb
1 of 3
17 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 1lb
In Stock 984
Our oldest white sharp cheddar cheese that is aged over 17 years. Extra Sharp with a crumbly texture. Has natural white color. No food coloring added. 1 lb.
Price$81.99
1 lb. Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax
1 lb. Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax
In Stock 9999845
1 lb. Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in black wax.
Price$24.99
1 lb. Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax
1 lb. Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax
In Stock 9712
1 lb. Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in red wax.
Price$16.99
True Blue Cheddar
1 of 3
True Blue Cheddar
In Stock 1500
Cheddar Cheese with chunks of Blue Cheese throughout. If you can't decide which one to put on your burger, why not have both! Weight: 1lb
Price$12.99
21 Year Sharp Cheddar 1lb
1 of 3
21 Year Sharp Cheddar 1lb
In Stock 3176
For an EXTREME sharp cheddar, the oldest yellow cheddar at Ehlenbach’s is now aged over 21 years.
Price$99.99
21 Year Sharp Cheddar 5lb
1 of 3
21 Year Sharp Cheddar 5lb
In Stock 9158
For an EXTREME sharp cheddar, the oldest yellow cheddar at Ehlenbach’s is now 21 years old.
Price$497.99
21 Year Sharp Cheddar 8 oz.
1 of 3
21 Year Sharp Cheddar 8 oz.
In Stock 47
For an EXTREME sharp cheddar, the oldest yellow cheddar at Ehlenbach’s is now aged over 21 years.
Price$49.99
3 Year Sharp Cheddar (1lb)
3 Year Sharp Cheddar (1lb)
In Stock 145
Aged over 3 years, with a sharp flavor and smooth texture.
Price$15.99
3 Year Sharp Cheddar (5.5lb)
3 Year Sharp Cheddar (5.5lb)
In Stock 4
Aged over 3 years, with a sharp flavor and smooth texture.
Price$85.99
5 Year Sharp Cheddar (1lb)
1 of 3
5 Year Sharp Cheddar (1lb)
In Stock 9456
Aged over 5 years, with a very sharp flavor and semi-dry texture. 
Price$21.99
5 Year Sharp Cheddar (5.5lb)
1 of 3
5 Year Sharp Cheddar (5.5lb)
In Stock 9892
Aged over 5 years, with a very sharp flavor and semi-dry texture. 
Price$118.99
6 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 1lb
6 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 1lb
In Stock 150
White sharp cheddar aged over 6 years. Semi-crumbly texture. Has natural white color. No food coloring added. 1 lb.
Price$24.99
6 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 5.5lb
6 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 5.5lb
In Stock 2
White sharp cheddar aged over 6 years. Semi-crumbly texture. Has natural white color. No food coloring added. 5.5 lbs.
Price$134.99
8 Year Old Sharp Cheddar 1lb
8 Year Old Sharp Cheddar 1lb
In Stock 3640
Extra sharp cheddar aged by us over 8 years. Very sharp flavor. Texture is very dry and crumbly. This cheese is one of our specialties! 1 lb.
Price$30.99
8 Year Old Sharp Cheddar 5 lb
8 Year Old Sharp Cheddar 5 lb
In Stock 10148
Extra sharp cheddar aged by us for over 8 years. Very sharp flavor. Texture is very dry and crumbly. This cheese is one of our specialties! 5 lbs. 
Price$167.99
9 Year Old Sharp Cheddar 1lb
9 Year Old Sharp Cheddar 1lb
In Stock 3642
Extra sharp cheddar aged by us over 9 years. Very sharp flavor. Texture is very dry and crumbly. This cheese is one of our specialties! 1 lb.
Price$34.99
9 Year Old Sharp Cheddar 5 lb
9 Year Old Sharp Cheddar 5 lb
In Stock 10149
Extra sharp cheddar aged by us for over 9 years. Very sharp flavor. Texture is very dry and crumbly. This cheese is one of our specialties! 5 lbs. 
Price$172.99
« Previous1234 »

© 2019 - 2026 Page 1 SEO Design, All rights reserved.

Responsive / Mobile Websites, Website Design, Hosting & SEO by Page 1 SEO Design LLC