4879 County Road V
DeForest, WI 53532
Phone: 608-846-4791
Fax: 608-846-4793

0 Product(s) in cart |
Total $0.00 |
 Shopping cart
Not logged in

CATEGORIES


Cheddars

Our award-winning cheddars aged right here on site! From mild cheddar all the way up to 16-year-old cheddar! We have the cheddars aimed to please!

Home
» Cheddars
Sort by
11 Year Sharp Cheddar 1lb
11 Year Sharp Cheddar 1lb
In Stock 996
Extra sharp cheddar aged by us over 11 years. 1 lb.
Price$45.99
11 Year Sharp Cheddar 5.5lb
11 Year Sharp Cheddar 5.5lb
In Stock 100
Extra sharp cheddar aged by us over 11 years. 5.5 lbs.
Price$250.99
16 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 1lb
16 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 1lb
In Stock 2088
Our oldest white sharp cheddar cheese that is aged over 16 years. Extra Sharp with a  crumbly texture. Has natural white color. No food coloring added. 1 lb.
Price$75.99
16 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 5.5lb
16 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 5.5lb
In Stock 9628
Our oldest white sharp cheddar cheese that is aged over 16 years. Extra Sharp with a  crumbly texture. Has natural white color. No food coloring added. 5.5 lb.
Price$415.99
1 lb. Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax
1 lb. Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax
In Stock 9999907
1 lb. Five Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in black wax.
Price$24.99
1 lb. Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax
1 lb. Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Wax
In Stock 9767
1 lb. Two Year Old Sharp Cheddar Cheese dipped in red wax.
Price$16.99
True Blue Cheddar
True Blue Cheddar
In Stock 1
Cheddar Cheese with chunks of Blue Cheese throughout. If you can't decide which one to put on your burger, why not have both! Weight: 1lb
Price$12.99
2 Year Sharp Cheddar (1lb)
2 Year Sharp Cheddar (1lb)
In Stock 498
Aged over 2 years, with a sharp flavor and smooth texture.
Price$12.99
2 Year Sharp Cheddar (5.5lb)
2 Year Sharp Cheddar (5.5lb)
In Stock 100
Aged over 2 years, with a sharp flavor and smooth texture.
Price$68.95
20 Year Sharp Cheddar 1lb
20 Year Sharp Cheddar 1lb
In Stock 3245
For an EXTREME sharp cheddar, the oldest yellow cheese at Ehlenbach’s is now aged over 20 years, with a wonderful taste that really knocks your socks off! 1 lb.
Price$99.99
20 Year Sharp Cheddar 5lb
20 Year Sharp Cheddar 5lb
In Stock 9158
For an EXTREME sharp cheddar, the oldest yellow cheese at Ehlenbach’s is now 20 years old, with a wonderful taste that really knocks your socks off! 5 lbs.
Price$547.99
3 Year Sharp Cheddar (1lb)
3 Year Sharp Cheddar (1lb)
In Stock 0
Aged over 3 years, with a sharp flavor and smooth texture.
Price$15.99
3 Year Sharp Cheddar (5.5lb)
3 Year Sharp Cheddar (5.5lb)
In Stock 0
Aged over 3 years, with a sharp flavor and smooth texture.
Price$85.99
4 Year Sharp Cheddar (1lb)
4 Year Sharp Cheddar (1lb)
In Stock 9569
Aged over 4 years, with a very sharp flavor and semi-dry texture. 
Price$18.99
4 Year Sharp Cheddar (5.5lb)
4 Year Sharp Cheddar (5.5lb)
In Stock 9894
Aged over 4 years, with a very sharp flavor and semi-dry texture. 
Price$101.99
6 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 1lb
6 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 1lb
In Stock 9783
White sharp cheddar aged over 6 years. Semi-crumbly texture. Has natural white color. No food coloring added. 1 lb.
Price$24.99
6 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 5.5lb
6 Year Old White Sharp Cheddar 5.5lb
In Stock 900
White sharp cheddar aged over 6 years. Semi-crumbly texture. Has natural white color. No food coloring added. 5.5 lbs.
Price$134.99
7 Year Old Sharp Cheddar 1lb
7 Year Old Sharp Cheddar 1lb
In Stock 3787
Extra sharp cheddar aged by us over 7 years. Very sharp flavor. Texture is very dry and crumbly. This cheese is one of our specialties! 1 lb.
Price$27.99
« Previous1234 »

© 2019 - 2025 Page 1 SEO Design, All rights reserved.

Responsive / Mobile Websites, Website Design, Hosting & SEO by Page 1 SEO Design LLC